Tessa Fox Reads
  • Home
  • Blog
  • About Me

Don't judge a book by its movie

10/6/2014

2 Comments

 
Picture
Image via World of Entertainment / http://worldofentertainment.info
The way I see it, there are two types of people in this world: Those who insist on reading the book before watching the television show or movie, and those who prefer to watch a story unfold on the screen before picking up the book. 

I, most definitely, am the former. I always read the book first. Always. 

With the book-turned-movie "Gone Girl" now in theaters, I find myself – yet again – putting off a trip to the cinema until I turn that final page. I love comparing books and movies, but only after I read the work in its original and intended form. As someone who hopes to have a published novel one day, I feel it's only fair to the author to read before watching. But that's not the only reason I always choose books first.

I love books because of how they make you use your imagination. When you read a book, you create the images of the characters and settings based simply on the author's descriptive words. But when you watch the movie first, those images are spoon-fed to you, and they're not your own. They're some Hollywood big shot's interpretation of an author's descriptions. On the rare (and most of the time, accidental) occasions where I read the book after watching a visual adaptation, I found it hard not picture the film's actors and actresses instead of creating my own images. Where's the creativity in that?

And let's face it, the sense of accomplishment you feel after finishing a 900-page book just isn't the same as ejecting a 120-minute DVD from its player. A lot more work goes into reading a book, and if you're already familiar with a story because you binge-watched the first season on HBO GO, you probably won't have that same motivation to read it cover to cover. 

The book is always so much more detailed than the movie or television show. The complainer in me prefers to grumble about what was left out in the movie rather than admit, "Oh, that makes more sense now. They didn't really explain all that back story in the movie."

I often ask people which method they prefer, and when they tell me they're movie-then-book people I make them defend their reasons. They normally say something along the lines of not wanting to ruin the movie by reading the book first, which is a fair enough answer – because movies can be ruined. Books cannot.

Based on my very unscientific conclusions of non-randomized sampling, I've found that despite people's reading-watching preferences, they always say the same thing: The book is always better.

And there's no arguing with that.

2 Comments
Alex Bauer
10/6/2014 09:35:35 am

I agree with a lot of your points Tessa, however I do like watching films before reading the book just to see the similarities and differences between the two mediums. Some of my favorites are Burgess/Kubrick's "A Clockwork Orange", Easton-Ellis/Harron's "American Psycho", and Kesey/Forman's"One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest", however I am biased as I'm a film studies student.

Reply
Tessa Fox
10/7/2014 02:05:23 am

Thanks for your comment, Alex! A Clockwork Orange is definitely one of my favorite books-into-movies! Just like you're biased, so am I! :)

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Tessa Fox is the Early Literacy Librarian at the Kenosha Public Library. After working in the journalism and publishing fields, Tessa decided to dedicate her life to books and public librarianship, and went back to school to get her Master's in Library and Information Science from the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee, where she graduated in December 2016. Tessa has been working in public libraries since 2014. Disclaimer: The views expressed here are mine alone and do not reflect those of my employer.


    Connect with me online!

    Picture

    Picture
    Picture

    Picture

    Tweets by @TessaFoxReads

    Archives

    April 2020
    December 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    July 2017
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014


    Categories

    All
    Adult
    Audiobooks
    Banned Books
    Best Picture Books Of The Year
    Book Contests
    Book Crafts
    Book Displays
    Book Lists
    Book News
    Book Reviews
    Books
    Bookshelves
    Bookstores
    Booktalking
    Book Trivia
    Children
    Children's Books
    Community Library
    Diversity And Inclusion
    DIY
    Fantasy
    Favorite Books
    Feminism
    Fiction
    Girl Power Books
    Halloween
    Historical Fiction
    Horror
    Humor
    Kenosha
    Kenosha Public Library
    Librarian
    Librarianship
    Libraries Now A Day In The Life
    Library
    Library And Information Science
    Library Contests
    Library Ideas
    Library Internships
    Library News
    Library Programs
    Mainstream Fiction
    Mike De Sisti
    Milwaukee
    Milwaukee Public Library
    MLIS
    Mobile Libraries
    Movies
    MPL Express
    Mystery
    Nonfiction
    Personal
    Picture Books
    Poetry
    Politics
    Public Library
    Quotations
    Reading
    Refurbished Furniture
    Representation
    Romance
    Science Fiction
    Sci-Fi
    Seasonal
    Self-publishing
    Social Media
    South Milwaukee Public Library
    Storytime
    Summer Reading Programs
    Technology
    Television
    The Journal Sentinel
    Thriller
    UWM Grad School
    UWM School Of Information Studies
    Video
    Webinars
    Western
    What I'm Reading
    Why Books Matter
    Why Libraries Matter
    Women's Fiction
    Writing
    Young Adult
    Youth Services

    RSS Feed